Showing posts with label Endangered. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Endangered. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 7, 2023

Petition: Require a full Biological Survey before Timex Site Development

Middlebury, CT:  The Conservation Commission should require a full biological and habitat study of the Timex Site before approving any redevelopment plans.

Petition · Require a full Biological Survey before Timex Site Development · Change.org


BACKGROUND:

Drubner Equities, LLC has proposed Southford Park, a 720,000 +/- sf warehouse/distribution buildings with associated access, parking and loading areas on two parcels of land: the Timex World Headquarters at 555 Christian Rd. and 764 Southford Rd. in Middlebury, CT. The site plan calls for the destruction of 15,000+ sf of wetlands, and would disturb an additional 7+ acres in the 100 ft upland review area. 

A group of concerned citizens founded the Middlebury Small Town Alliance (MSTA) to oppose this project. The MSTA filed for Intervenor status, and hired a lawyer and expert witnesses to provide critical testimony to the Conservation Commission about the unreasonable level of pollution this project would generate for surrounding sensitive environmental receptors.

At its February 28th meeting, the Middlebury Conservation Commission heard reports from the Peer Reviewer it hired to review the applicant's plans as well as the experts hired by the MSTA. Based on that evidence, the Commission declared the proposed redevelopment of the Timex Headquarters would have a "significant impact" on the existing wetlands on the property, and it scheduled a public hearing for March 28th at 7pm. According to testimony presented by Dr. Stephen Danzer, a nationally certified Soil Scientist, Professional Wetlands Scientist, and Certified Arborist, the Conservation Commission could deny the application simply for the fact that this project would eliminate wetlands from the site, no further information needed.

The Conservation Commission hired a Peer Reviewer because Commission members are only volunteers, and they lack the specific scientific and engineering knowledge to critically evaluate the applicant's proposal. For the same reason, the Commission should also require a full biological and habitat study of the Timex Property before any redevelopment is allowed. Physically marking the boundaries of wetlands is only half the job of an impact study: if a project proposes to destroy wetlands, the Conservation Commission should also know exactly what plant and animal species will be affected by this loss of habitat.

The MSTA had hired the experts necessary to conduct this study, but was denied access to the property by the applicant. The applicant claims there is no need for a biological study because the Natural Diversity Data Base (NDDB) doesn't identify any species of concern on the Timex property. This is only a partial truth: if no one ever looked for threatened or endangered species on the Timex Property, the NDDB would indeed show nothing has been found there. You can't know for sure until you look, and the MSTA believes the Conservation Commission has no business approving this project unless it has done its due diligence in every way possible.

Since the Conservation Commission is responsible for the protection, preservation, maintenance and use of the inland wetlands and watercourses in the Town of Middlebury by minimizing their disturbance and pollution, it is the Commission's highest obligation to ensure that any proposed project fully complies with Middlebury's Inland Wetlands & Watercourse Regulations. It's not the Commission's job to "work" with a developer to find common ground acceptable to both parties: the application either complies with our regulations or it doesn't. If the applicant can't produce a site plan that complies with our regulations, the Commission is obligated to deny the application.

This petition is your chance to vote for the protection of natural resources in Middlebury. The Conservation Commission scheduled a public hearing to better understand your view on the destruction of wetlands: here's your chance to ask the town to fully investigate the consequences of approving this project.




Thursday, February 23, 2023

As Tuesday’s Conservation Commission Meeting Approaches

As Tuesday’s Conservation Commission meeting approaches (2/28 @7:30pm at Shepardson Community Center and on Zoom at https://us02web.zoom.us/j/81463100713?pwd=dzRIU3NCdDF×STdiSGOOdEc2RkpsZz09), the MSTA has the following update:

  • The Peer Reviewer hired by the town has completed his report.
  • The experts hired by the MSTA have reviewed this report and are prepared to reply at Tuesday’s meeting.
  • We anticipate the Conservation Commission making a decision on Tuesday night, so it is critical that people are at the meeting or watching on Zoom. If the Commission approves this project, they’ll have to do it with everyone watching.
  • If you want to submit your objection to the Conservation Commission, please send an email addressed to the Conservation Commission, ℅ of the MSTA at middlebury.small.town.alliance@gmail.com. The Wetlands Officer only works on Wednesday mornings, so we’ll hand in letters in person on Tuesday night to ensure they are included in the record. We’ll take printed out or handwritten letters as well as long as you can get them to one of us by Tuesday afternoon at 4pm. Send us a heads up via email or FB, and we’ll make arrangements to connect with you.
  • No full biological assessment of the Timex property has been made (meaning no one went looking for endangered plants or animals). The application was initially submitted in November, so everything would have been hibernating at that point anyway. However, the MSTA made arrangements for a herpetologist to evaluate potential habitats (ribbon snake in particular), and we were denied access to the property to complete this evaluation. The real price of the denial is once again born by Middlebury residents: the town missed a golden opportunity to gather yet another layer of information critical to making an informed decision on the impact of approving this project. If the town is going to approve the complete destruction of wetlands, it should have at least evaluated what plants and animals live there first. The Natural Diversity Data Base (NDDB) identifies threatened species very near to the Timex property, and the applicant argued the NDDB didn’t show anything of concern on the property. While this is technically true, the NDDB is a look backwards at what has been found in the past. If no one ever evaluated the Timex property for endangered plants or animals, the NDDB would be incomplete because no one ever looked, not because there isn’t anything important on site. If the town accepts the applicant’s argument that there is nothing to look for, the town is turning a blind eye to willful habitat destruction and further endangering the plants and animals it has a duty to protect. This is simply unacceptable from the MSTA’s point of view, and it demonstrates a complete failure to govern properly.




Support the Alliance

Name

Email *

Message *

Featured Post

Legal Update on Southford Park